Göksu Safi Işık Attorney Partnership Logo First
Göksu Safi Işık Attorney Partnership Logo 2

Insights
GSI Articletter
GSI Brief

Trademark Infringements On The Internet And Relevant Measures

2018 - Winter Issue

Download As PDF
Share
Print
Copy Link

Trademark Infringements On The Internet And Relevant Measures

BankingFinance
2018
GSI Teampublication
00:00
-00:00

ABSTRACT

Nowadays, it is obvious that the internet, which has become indispensable, has shown impact on every field especially including trade. The fact that the internet allows interaction among people easily and quickly even across the continents, is causing many transactions on the commercial side to take place on the internet and also various types of violations. One of the most common of these legal problems is trademark violation. With the advent of internet-based advertising, the trademark right has gained more value in our day. In the face of trademark being both material and immaterial value, various protection mechanisms against trademark right violations have currently regulated. For this reason, the main types of the trademark right violations in the internet are discussed and the scope of protection regulated in various legislation is examined in our article.

I. INTRODUCTION

A trademark is a distinctive and determinative element for business enterprises and individuals, which can constitute a material value independently of the enterprise creating it. It provides a certain quality, credibility and reputation by symbolizing the product and its manufacturer. For this reason, it is observed that the trademark is used to gain unfair profits by non-entitled people. With the widespread use of the internet and the facilitation of communication and trade among people, the contrary acts to the law have often been encountered on the internet. 

In this respect, in our article, the trademark violations that occurred within the scope of internet advertising, internet domain names, search engine advertising and spamming, which are the most common forms of trademark violations in the internet field, are examined; the legal remedies against these violations and the persons to be held responsible are explained.

II. VIOLATION OF TRADEMARK THROUGH INTERNET ADVERTISING

A. Search Engine Advertising and AdWords Advertisement (Keyword) System

A significantly large number of information and data flows happen on internet every single minute. The challenges, which users may face in finding what they are searching for on the internet have caused to develop search engines such as Google, Yahoo and Yandex. When users want to access a data, they enter the keyword/keywords that they think are relevant to the searching data in search engines and so that, the data among the scattered data on the internet is listed from the most relevant result to the least relevant one with the keyword. Various algorithms are used to determine the most relevant data. However, search engines allow users to be placed in the top rankings by advertising, even if they are not the most relevant to the search. However, this practice brought some legal problems, including trademark violation and unfair competition. Deceptive advertising and trademark violations resulting from the difficulty in distinguishing which content is being advertised by users and which content is objectively placed in the top position due to the most relevant algorithm had let to the discussions of this application in search engines1. 

Therefore, search engines have begun to explicitly specify the advertised content. However, this situation could not prevent trademark violation and unfair competition claims. 

As described above, the AdWords Advertising System is shaped by that websites which are ranked high in the relevant data list that are accessed with using keyword/ keywords by giving advertisement, and this system constitutes a large part of search engine advertising. As a result of lengthy discussions, AdWords advertisements are often shown as sponsor links in the results page, independently of objective search results2. These advertisements are primarily financed via cost-per-click and cost-per-impression systems3.

This system is reflected in Industrial Property Law4 No. 6769 (“IPL”), in terms of trademark protection, with keyword and router code terms. Accordingly, in the event that the domain name, the router code, the keyword or the alike mark is used in the same way or in a similar manner to create a commercial effect on the internet by people who have rights on the trademark or who do not have a legitimate connection with the trademark, the owner has the right to prohibit such use5. Therefore, trademark owners may apply to legal remedies against violation of their rights in relation to AdWords advertisements.

B. Spamming

Spamming is an advertising activity in which unwanted commercial messages are posted and e-mails are sent serially. Spam can be defined as a non-personal message that is sent to the user to attract attention and to convince, usually bearing the sponsor’s statement and received against the user’s request6.

Trademark violation often happens through an intense advertising activity in spamming by usually using the same or similar marks with well-known trademarks. Regarding the subject, “use of the mark in the business documents and advertisements of the undertaking” is under the protection of the trademark right in IPL and in such a case the right to prohibit the aforementioned use is given to the right holder if the mark is used in trade area7.

However, the article 6 of the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce8 No.6563 (“E-Commerce Law”) states that commercial electronic messages may only be sent with prior approval and that the approval may be obtained in writing or by using any electronic communication tools. But, if the recipient of the message intentionally provides his contact information, it is stated that no further approval is required for commercial electronic messages regarding modification, use and maintenance of the goods or services. 

Moreover, the article 7 of the E-Commerce Law regulates the content of the commercial electronic communication and it is stipulated that the content of the commercial electronic communication should be in accordance with the approval given by the recipient. It is also emphasized that the message should include the accessible contact information that identifies the service provider9. In addition to this, it is also arranged that the subject of the message, its purpose and, if it is made on behalf of another person, the information about this person should take place in the content. 

Recipients have the right to refuse to receive commercial electronic messages without any reason. The service provider is responsible for ensuring that the rejection notice is easily and freely available via electronic communication tools and providing the necessary information regarding the rejection notice in the messages it sends. Within three business days of receipt of the refusal request, the service provider shall cease sending electronic messages to the recipient10.

III. DOMAIN NAME TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENTS

In order for computers to recognize each other within the Internet network, each has its own unique address which is called the Internet Protocol (“IP”) address. The IP addresses that were numerically expressed in the beginning became words later, so domain names given to IP addresses are more important now. Previously, the first-come first-served principle has been applied to the distribution of domain names11. A trademark is any kind of mark that distinguishes a good or service from others and is in the form of words, shapes, colors, letters, numbers, voices, and the form of goods or packages that characterize both the owner and the good or service. The first-come first-served principle caused the registration of domain names consisting of names of famous people and well-known trademarks by other people to their own against the trademark and name right, and then to be sold to real right holders at very high prices. In addition to this, it is also a common problem to obtain unfair profits by benefiting from the reputation and commercial potential of well-known firms and people. 

IPL regulates that similar marks which are the same as or not distinguishable from the trademark which had been registered for the same or the similar kind of goods or services or which had been made application for registration in a previous date cannot be registered as a trademark12 In addition, as will be explained in more detail below13, the violation of the trademark will also be the subject of a lawsuit filed by the right holder. In addition, the Internet Corporation or the Assigned Names and Numbers (“ICANN”) Arbitration Procedure is being applied for international domain name disputes.

IV. LEGAL REMEDIES

A. People Responsible for Infringements on Internet

1. Access Provider

Access provider is a type of internet service provider that rents computer equipment belonging to the user from the local network or connects them to each other and other internet service providers14 via lines it owns15.

In the Law on the Arrangement of Publications Made on the Internet and the Struggle Against the Crimes Processed Through These Publications No.5651 (“Internet Law”), the access provider is briefly defined as any natural or legal person who provides access to the internet to its users16.

2. Hosting Provider

Hosting provider is defined as a natural or legal person who provides or operates systems that contain services and content in Internet Law Art.2. It uses its own computer as a kind of tool to connect the user with the data on the internet.

3. Content Provider

Content providers are real or legal entities that produce, modify, and provide any information or data presented to users over the internet17. For example, people uploading video to video sharing sites are content providers; the person hosting the system that will publish this sharing site will also be the hosting provider.

4. Responsibility Regime

The Turkish Commercial Law18 No. 6102 (“TCL”), the E-Commerce Law, the Internet Law and the IPL are the main legal texts regulating the application ways for violations on the internet. At this stage, it is considered useful to explain the provisions related to the subject in question.

a. Responsibility regime according to TCL

Behaviors and commercial practices that are deceptive or unfairly affecting relations among competitors or between suppliers and customers are defined unjustified and unlawful19. Unfair acts and practices in this context constitute unfair competition. In this respect, the responsibilities of internet service providers due to unfair competition have been regulated in TCL. If there are unfair competition conditions20 against trademark violations made via the internet, these special regulations shall be applied. Accordingly, if transmission has not yet been started, the recipient of the transmission or the person competed unfairly has not been selected the content or changed it to do an unlawful act, it will not be possible to file a lawsuit and to take injunction decision against the service provider due to unfair competition in the computing field. If the unfair competition action has negative consequences or would cause great damage, the court would take a injunction decision to terminate or prevent unfair competition act against the service provider with listening the service provider or take other applicable measures to the subject matter21.

b. Responsibility regime regulated in E-Commerce Law

The service provider is defined as real or legal entities engaged in electronic commerce; intermediary service provider is defined as real or legal entities providing electronic trading field for the economic and commercial activities of others in E-Commerce Law22. Service providers are responsible for the storage and security of the personal data that they receive as a result of the transactions that they have made under the aforementioned law. They have an obligation to not disclose personal data to third parties without the consent of the owner and not to use it for other purposes23.

On the other hand, intermediary service providers are not obliged to check the content provided by real or legal entities using the electronic field in which they serve, and to investigate whether there is any unlawful activity or situation related to the content and the relevant goods or services24.

In addition, for commercial electronic transmissions, service providers also have various obligations as explained above25.

c. Responsibility regime in Internet Law

The obligations of the content provider, the hosting provider and the access provider are separately indicated in the Internet Law. The content provider is responsible for any content that is put on the internet by himself, but is not responsible for the content of the other party to whom it is linked. If it is clearly understood from the way he presents it, that the content provider has embraced the content of another person and purposed to enable the users to reach the content in question, he will be responsible in accordance with the general provisions26.

The hosting provider is not obliged to check the content it provides or to investigate whether there is an unlawful activity. However, if the hosting provider is informed that the content provided by himself is illegal, he is obliged to remove the content from the publication according to the censorship and the prohibition of access provisions27 under the Internet Law28. 

Finally, the access provider is obliged to prevent access to any illegal content published by any user, in the case that he is informed in accordance with the prohibition of access provisions of the Internet Law. The access provider is not obliged to check whether the contents of the information accessed through him are unlawful or causing liability29. 

Even though the content provider is not responsible for the content of others and the hosting provider and the access provider do not have responsibility with regard the unlawful contents, the actual and legal persons whose rights are violated can claim, according to Article 9 of the Internet Law, the relevant content to be removed. The Law regulates the implementation of the warning system in case of violation of personality rights in Article 9 and does not mention the rights of intellectual property. Therefore it is not clear if this article is applicable in case trademark violations.

d. Responsibility regime in IPL

IPL is the main law regulating the scope of trademark right and the legal remedies against violations. According to IPL30: 

“(2) The rights arising from trademark registration belong exclusively to the trademark owner. The trademark owner is entitled to demand the prevention of the following acts in the case that they are made without permission of the trademark owner; 

a) Any mark that is the same as the registered trademark, used in the goods or services included in the registration. 

b) Use any mark which is the same as or similar to the registered trademark and covers the same or similar goods or services as the goods or services covered by the registered trademark, and because of these reasons they may be confused and associated with the trademark registered by the public. 

c) Use any mark unfairly, regardless of whether they are in the same, similar or different goods or services, which is the same as or similar to the registered trademark and which has an unfair advantage from the reputation of the mark due to the level of recognition in Turkey or which would damage its reputation or damage its distinguishing character.” 

IPL Art.7/3-d has exclusively regulated the unfair use of any mark, which constitutes a trademark, in a way creating commercial effect on the internet and it has stipulated that such use of the mark is prohibited in accordance with the above mentioned provision. According to IPL Art.29, such uses considered violation of the trademark unless approved by the owner of the trademark.

B. Legal Remedies

1. Detection, Suspension and Prevention Case Against Infringement of the Right to Trademark

The trademark infringement case will be filed by the owner of the trademark against the infringement of his right is regulated in the IPL. If it requires the presence of the infringement to be accepted by a court decision, detection case; if there is an ongoing infringement, suspension case; if there is a potential danger of an infringement, the prevention case should be brought. It should be accepted that the request of the abolition of infringement is broadly interpreted, so that it includes the request for the abandonment of the trade name, the business name or domain name which relate to the infringing element31.

Some situations are regulated as infringement of the trademark right in the SMK. Accordingly, if the trademark is/was used, without the consent of the trademark owner, in the ways32 that the right owner allowed to prohibit according to the SMK, infringement occurs. Imitation of a trademark by using same or indistinguishable mark without the trademark owner permission is also considered infringement. Another form of infringement is to sell, distribute, put on trade field in a different way, import, export, hold for commercial purposes or to make suggestion to make a contract for these products, which have the mark used by infringement, by using trademark or similar enough to be indistinguishable mark. In addition, the unauthorized extension of a license granted by trademark owner or the transfer of these rights to third parties may also be subject to an infringement case33.

2. Pecuniary and Non-pecuniary Compensation Cases

Acts that infringe the trademark may damage the trademark owner’s economic activities, diminish the distinctive nature of the trademark, or create consequences that may disturb the customer’s confidence in the trademark34. Any damages caused by infringements should be compensated. 

The rights granted to the owner, because they are valid as of the publication date of the trademark registration against the third parties, the owner of the trademark is entitled to file a case for damages according to IPL, in the event that the trademark owner can forbid the use of the mark after the trademark registration is announced35. In case of infringement of the industrial property right, if the reputation of the industrial property is damaged because of that the goods or services subject to the right are used in bad faith or produced by the infringer, the products produced in such a way are supplied, or they are put on the market in inappropriate way, compensation may be required36. The damage of the trademark owner will also cover the actual loss and the loss of profit37. 

In practice, advertising expenditures, expenses related to the identification of evidence of the infringement, costs of proceedings, and expenses of publicity made to public for the reputation of the mark are required as actual loss38. Within the scope of the loss of profit; the demands for the inability to sell products produced due to the inability to enter the market effectively, the waste of investments and the wages paid to the employed persons are put forward39.

In addition, it may be required a non-pecuniary compensation for the breach of the distinctive nature of the mark, loss of confidence in the mark and loss of respectability40.

3. Preliminary Injunctions

Persons, who are entitled to file a lawsuit by the IPL, has the right to ask the court to order a preliminary injunction in order to ensure the effectiveness of the decision by proving that the act subjected to dispute is or very likely to cause an infringement of their own industrial property rights. The preliminary injunction regulated in this case covers to prevent and stop the relevant action; to confiscate and store of the products, which are produced or imported by infringement of the industrial property right, the instruments exclusively used in the production of these products or in the performance of the method with patent in the borders of Turkey including areas such as customs and free port. It shall also include measures to provide guarantees for the compensation of any loss41.

4. Other Legal Remedies

With this the general framework, there are also different legal remedies for violations in the field of internet. At this point, it will be necessary to refer to the Internet Law and the Intellectual and Artistic Works Law42 No. 5846 (“IAWL”). 

According to the article 9 of the Internet Law, real and legal persons, institutions and organizations claiming that their personal rights are violated due to the content published in the internet field may request to be removed from content provider or by applying to the hosting provider if they cannot reach content provider with the warning system. In addition, they also have the right to appeal directly to the criminal court of peace to demand to block access to content. Even if the trademark right is not regulated as a direct personality right; all the elements that can belong to the legal entity such as legal entity name, trade name, business name, sign, emblem, catalog, trademark and all the distinguishing instruments should be considered as the personality rights of the legal person. The Civil Law does not regulate the right to personality exclusively. With the developing technology, new appearances of the violations of personality rights have emerged. So that the limits of the personality rights have expanded and the trademark right has become a personality right specific to legal entities. As a matter of fact, there are precedent decisions that the Supreme Court has given in this respect43.

IAWL the additional article 4 is a substance with a wide range of applications in the preliminary injunctions44. Regarding the copyright rights and/or works belonging to the trademark subject to the infringement, it is regulated in the add. art. 4 of the IAWL that the information which is found on the works or is seen during the publication of the work, and the numbers or codes representing this information cannot be removed or altered unauthorized. The original or copies of the works that have been altered or removed this information without permission cannot be distributed, copied, distributed for import or presented to the public. 

In the event of violation of the rights of the rights owners and the rights of the connected owners by service and information content providers with tools of signaling, sound and / or image transmission including digital transmission, especially internet, the copyrighted works shall be removed from the content subject to violation by the appeal of the rights owners’. To do this, the right owner must first ask the information content provider for the violation to be stopped within three days. If the violation persists despite the application; upon application to the public prosecutor, within three days the service provider will be asked to stop the service provided to the information content provider. 

There is no specific regulation in the legislation related to the trademark whether to apply the “warn-off” method provided in Article 4 of the IAWL. In “Gitti Gidiyor decision45" of YHGK (Supreme Court Assembly of Civil Chambers), it has been argued that it should be taken directly by filing a lawsuit against the persons who participated in the infringement of trademark acts counted in Legislative Decree numbered 55646 (new IPL47) for removing the content. Participating people will only be liable if they are in fault in such a case. In order to be able to mention the fault in the violations made on the internet, the content should not be removed despite the warning. However, YHGK has foreseen that the lawsuit petition for the detection, prevention and elimination of the consequences of infringement will serve as a warning. In this case, even if the content is not removed, the resulting fault condition will be realized.

V. CONCLUSION

Not only the trademark right has a material value but also the reputation and dignity that it represents in commercial life, infringement of this rights causes significant damages. Along with the development of the internet, violations of trademark rights in various forms have also become widespread. Various legal regulations have been made in order to prevent those violations and the trademark right has been put under strict protection in general and for the internet exclusively. 

In our article, the most wide and common forms of violations are mentioned and the laws that are regulated against the trademark violations carried out on the internet are explained. As can be seen, there are many relevant legal regulations, and the rights are granted to the right owner to apply for various legal remedies in this sense. However, it is important to note that violations of trademarks on the internet may occur in many different ways, and the nature of these violations changes day by day. For this reason, it should be taken into consideration that the assessment should be made according to the nature of each case.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Eser Rüzgar, Marka Hakkının İnternet Reklamcılığı Yoluyla İhlali ve Sorumluluk Rejimi, On Iki Levha Yayıncılık, Istanbul 2013.

Emrehan İnal/Başak Baysal, Reklam Hukuku ve Uygulaması, On Iki Levha Yayıncılık, Istanbul 2008.

Hamdi Yasaman/Sıtkı Anlam Altay/Tolga Ayoğlu/Fülurya Yusufoğlu/ Sinan Yüksel, Marka Hukuku 556 Sayılı KHK Şerhi, Vol.1, Vedat Kitapçılık, Istanbul 2004.

Hasibe Işıklı, İnternet Alan İsimleri Sistemi Markalar ve Alan İsimleri Arasındaki İlişki, Ankara 2001 (Last Access: 01.10.2017) http://www.bilgitoplumu.gov.tr/wpcontent/uploads/2014/04/HasibeIsikli-Internet_Alan_Isimleri.pdf.

Murat Volkan Dülger/Yasin Beceni, Türkiye’de İnternet Sitelerinin Erişiminin Engellenmesi Konusunda Farklı Hukuk Disiplinleri Açısından Değerlendirilmeler, TÜSİAD March 2011 Report, Istanbul 2011.

Sefer Oğuz, İnternet Alan Adı Haklarının Korunması, Seçkin Yayıncılık, Ankara 2011.

Tamer Soysal, İnternet Servis Sağlayıcılarının Hukuki Sorumlulukları, Türkiye Barolar Birliği Dergisi (Turkish Bar Association Journal), November/December, Ankara 2005.

Uğur Çolak, Türk Marka Hukuku, On İki Levha Publication, Istanbul 2012.

Zeynep Kandemir, “Vuitton–Google Kararı”, Fikri Mülkiyet Hukuku Yıllığı 2010, On Iki Levha Yayıncılık, Istanbul 2011.

FOOTNOTE

1 Eser Rüzgar, Marka Hakkının İnternet Reklamcılığı Yoluyla İhlali ve Sorumluluk Rejimi, On Iki Levha Yayıncılık, Istanbul 2013, p.150.

2 Zeynep Kandemir, “Vuitton–Google Kararı”, Fikri Mülkiyet Hukuku Yıllığı 2010, On Iki Levha Yayıncılık, Istanbul 2011, p.317.

3 Emrehan İnal/Başak Baysal, Reklam Hukuku ve Uygulaması, On Iki Levha Yayıncılık, Istanbul 2008, p.103.

4 Official Gazette (“OG”) dated 10.01.2017 and numbered 29944.

5 Industrial Property Law No.6769 (“IPL”) Art. 7/3.

6 Sefer Oğuz, İnternet Alan Adı Haklarının Korunması, Seçkin Yayıncılık, Ankara 2011, p.289.

7 IPL Art.7/3.

8 OG dated 23.10.2014 and numbered 29166.

9 E-Commerce Law Art. 2/ç;“The service provider: Real or legal persons engaged in electronic trade”.

10 E-Commerce Law Art. 8.

11 Hasibe Işıklı, İnternet Alan İsimleri Sistemi Markalar ve Alan İsimleri Arasındaki İlişki, Ankara 2001, p.10. (Last Access: 01.10.2017) http://www. bilgitoplumu.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/ HasibeIsikli-Internet_Alan_Isimleri.pdf

12 IPL Art.5/1.

13 For more information, see the title “IV/B/a of this article.

14 Rüzgar, p.120-121, “…in general, legal or real persons providing infrastructure or any kind of services in the internet field will be generally referred to as ‘service providers’. If they are providers of access, location or content, there are subheadings under the title of internet service provider.”

15 Tamer Soysal, İnternet Servis Sağlayıcılarının Hukuki Sorumlulukları, Türkiye Barolar Birliği Dergisi (Turkish Bar Association Journal), November/ December, Ankara 2005, p.311.

16 OG No. 26530, dated 23.05.2007, Internet Law Art.2/1.

17 Internet Law Art.2/1.

18 OG dated 14.02.2011 and numbered 27846.

19 TCL Art.54/2.

20 TCL Art.55.

21 TCL Art.58/4.

22 E-Commerce Law Art.2/1.

23 E-commerce Law Art.10/1.

24 E-Commerce Law, Art.9/1 and Regulation on Service Provider and Intermediary Service Provider in Electronic Commerce, OG dated 26.08.2015, and numbered 29457, Art.6/4.

25 For detailed information see our article’s “II./B. Spamming” heading.

26 Internet Law Art.4.

27 Internet Law Art.8, 8/A, 9.

28 Internet Law Art.5.

29 Internet Law Art.6.

30 IPL Art.7/2.

31 Hamdi Yasaman/Sıtkı Anlam Altay/ Tolga Ayoğlu/Fülurya Yusufoğlu/Sinan Yüksel, Marka Hukuku 556 Sayılı KHK Şerhi, Vol.1, Vedat Kitapçılık, Istanbul 2004, p.1124.

32 IPL Art.7.

33 IPL Art.29.

34 Rüzgar, p. 281-282.

35 IPL Art.7/4.

36 IPL Art.150/2.

37 IPL Art.151/1.

38 Rüzgar, p. 284.

39 Uğur Çolak, Türk Marka Hukuku, On İki Levha Yayıncılık, Istanbul 2012, p.759.

40 Yasaman/Altay/Ayoğlu/Yusufoğlu/ Yüksel, p.1133.

41 IPL Art.159.

42 OG dated 13.12.1951 and numbered 7981.

43 Supreme Court 4th Civil Chamber, dated 24.09.2001, numbered 2001/4164 E., 2001/8421 K.

44 Murat Volkan Dülger/Yasin Beceni, Türkiye’de İnternet Sitelerinin Erişiminin Engellenmesi Konusunda Farklı Hukuk Disiplinleri Açısından Değerlendirilmeler, TÜSİAD March 2011 Report, Istanbul 2011, p. 55.

45 Supreme Court General Assembly dated 15.01.2014 numbered 2013/11-1138E., 2014/16K.

46 Legislative Decree No.556 Art.61/(a), (c), (e).

47 IPL Art.29/(a), (c).

More Insights

Articletter / GSI Brief

GSI Brief & Legal Brief

GSI Brief 204

Gsi Brief 204

Brief
Read more
GSI Brief 205

Gsi Brief 205

Brief
Read more
GSI Brief 206

Gsi Brief 206

Brief
Read more
GSI Brief 207

Gsi Brief 207

Brief
Read more

Articletter - Winter Issue

The Effects Doctrine in Accordance with the Turkish Competition Law Legislation

The Effects Doctrine In Accordance With The Turkish Competition Law Legislation

2018
Read more
Damages Liability of the Seller Under United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods

Damages Liability Of The Seller Under United Nations Convention On Contracts For The International Sale Of Goods

2018
Read more
The Differences Between Incoterms 2010 Fca And Cip

The Differences Between Incoterms 2010 Fca And Cip

2018
Read more
Principle Of Good Faith In Determining The Juristicdion of ICSID and Commentary on the Phoenix Case

Principle Of Good Faith In Determining The Juristicdion Of Icsid And Commentary On The Phoenix Case

2018
Read more
Trademark Infringements On The Internet And Relevant Measures